Skip to content

Silent Sorority

Infertility Survivors Finally Heard

Menu
  • My Story
    • Silent Sorority: Memoir
    • Coming2Terms Blog
  • About
  • Bylined Work
    • Times of London: The False Hope of ‘Fertility’ Benefits
    • NYT Op-Ed: The Big IVF Add-on Racket
    • STAT: Dark side of IVF
    • Do à la carte menus serve infertility patients?
    • New York Times Op-Ed: Selling the Fantasy of Fertility
    • WIRED: The Sobering Facts About Egg Freezing
    • FORTUNE: The Tough Truth About Egg Freezing
    • The Huffington Post
    • Medium ‘Human Parts’
    • Seleni Institute
    • New York Times Motherlode
    • Infertility’s Emotional Impact
  • In the News
    • MSNBC: Childless Not By Choice
    • STAT: IVF ‘add-ons’ rest on shaky science
    • IVF ‘Add-On’ Procedures Offer False Hope
    • Named ‘Top Health Blogger’ by Health Magazine
    • The Globe and Mail
    • The New York Times
    • MarketWatch – 10 Things Fertility Clinics Won’t Say
    • Women’s eNews
    • Radio: Living Childfree
    • Yahoo Shine Health Feature
    • The Broad Side
    • ABC TV Interview
    • Redbook
  • ReproTech Medicine Reporting
Menu

Not All Mothers Are Sanctimommies, Hooray!

Posted on February 5, 2013February 11, 2021 by Pamela Tsigdinos

As part of my blogoversary week of lessons learned…

#2 The Blogosphere Can Foster Strange Bedfellows
One of the toughest aspects of being part of a group routinely held up for scrutiny (e.g. women without children) is facing detractors who feel perfectly at ease casting aspersions or passing value judgements on our lives. I don’t know about you, but I don’t particularly relish being put on the defensive.

That’s why it was with some relief — and a smidge of amusement — that I found myself witness to, rather than in the midst of, fur flying across the Internet. In this case the topic concerned a letter to a childless woman and, curiously, some of the most spirited protests came not from non-moms, but moms.

It began when writer and mother Janine Kovacs — who has since apologized — wrote “Maybe You Are Ready for Kids, You’re Just Not Paying Attention,” as part of a call for submissions to address the question, How Do You Know You’re Ready for Kids?” (ignoring I might add, the fact that not all can conceive, nor is adoption a sure thing for all who attempt it).

In her attempt to be “hip and edgy,” Ms. Kovacs copped to “trashing” what we later learned was a fictional friend, Doris. In reality Doris was a convenient literary device, a  punching bag composite representing women unsure about motherhood. The piece went viral and prompted more than a few angry comments and responses from writers, many of them mothers, taking Ms. Kovacs to task for:

  • —making moms appear “condescending and self-righteous,” per Linda Sharps
  • —and pointing out that “maybe the pressure she [Doris] feels to have children comes from a culture that values mothers, but not middle-aged career women.” (Thank you, Kerry Cohen, for highlighting this reality)
  • —implying that “raising children is the way to enlightenment, or that the alternate road leads to having nothing in life to care about…” (Kudos to Mary Elizabeth Williams whose Salon piece gave me the term sanctimommy for this headline).
See also  Born With Us vs. Them Tendencies, We Can Overcome Differences

What really lifted my heart is that after years of feeling maligned (can I get an “I hear you” from the non-moms?) in a society that dotes on parents, there were mothers like Sarah MacLaughlin eager to point out that:

…parenting is not the only endorphin-oxytocin-dopamine natural high out there. And it’s certainly not the only way for a woman to reach her highest potential—do you hold the same rite of passage to fatherhood as wholly necessary for a man? People everywhere soar high and engage in meaningful, excellent, and fulfilling lives without children.

Mary Elizabeth Williams added these friendly words of advice in her Salon piece, “The only person who can ever fulfill you is you, Doris. And you have infinite worth and value right now, just as you are. Don’t let anybody ever try to tell you otherwise.”

She also reminds us that:

zealotry springs not out of faith but doubt. If you’re cool in your own life choices, you don’t need to foist them on anybody else.

Words to heed. Amen, sister.

Yes, it seems women over the centuries have proven highly skilled at finding ways to provoke each other — whether SAHM vs. work-outside-the-home mothers, childfree vs. mothers of all kinds, infertiles vs. fertiles (guilty as charged!) and the list goes on.

It’s only natural that we get highly territorial when we’re feeling threatened or maligned, and there are times when legitimate beefs arise deserving spirited discussion and debate. That’s one of the beauties of the blogosphere.

You’ll hear more about various life paths and room for greater understanding in the Bitter Infertiles podcast interview conducted yesterday. More on that when it’s available for download. Meanwhile, thoughts welcome.

See also  Comprenez-Vous? Oui. We Understand Each Other

Updated: Here’s the blog post on the podcast.

Related Posts:

  • What's Your Litmus Test?
    What's Your Litmus Test?
  • Triggered In A Way I Didn't Expect
    Triggered In A Way I Didn't Expect
  • Don't Ignore...There's More Than One Infertility Ending
    Don't Ignore...There's More Than One Infertility Ending
  • Silent Sorority Gratitude and a Look Ahead to a New Generation
    Silent Sorority Gratitude and a Look Ahead to a New…
  • An Artist Shares Decades of Wisdom
    An Artist Shares Decades of Wisdom
  • Australian View: Why Waste a Good Flood?
    Australian View: Why Waste a Good Flood?

8 thoughts on “Not All Mothers Are Sanctimommies, Hooray!”

  1. luna says:
    February 5, 2013 at 6:31 am

    I read that all with amusement. while I don’t want to reduce myself to name calling here, I have to say she originally sounded like such a smug fertile (now sanctimom, even better). I especially appreciated her apology though. great post!

    Reply
  2. loribeth says:
    February 5, 2013 at 5:32 pm

    I’m glad she apologized, and she did sound sincere — but really, what did she think was going to happen when she wrote something like that??

    Reply
  3. Mali says:
    February 6, 2013 at 6:58 am

    I read the original post and the response in Salon, but not the rest of it, and not the apology, so thanks for flagging that. It was interesting to watch – and is I guess just a reminder that we should always employ our analytical and critical skills when reading opinions. Just because someone has a voice in Salon or wherever, doesn’t mean that they are actually talking sense, and it doesn’t mean they’ve even though through the implications of their words. The apology still annoyed me – it seemed she was more worried about how she was perceived, than the judgements she had made. And it frustrates me that there are so many good writers who don’t have that opportunity to reach such a wide audience – you, for one!

    Reply
    1. Pamela says:
      February 6, 2013 at 9:40 am

      You are too kind, Mali. Thank you — and yes, I hear you — there is a touch of the “sorry I got beaten up, but not entirely sorry for what I said…” vibe to the apology.

      Reply
  4. AJLonesome says:
    February 7, 2013 at 12:21 am

    Seeing the quote from Sarah MacLaughlin made me want to shed tears of joy. NEVER have I heard a mother express that she thought a non-mom could have a fulfilled, complete life with no shortages or chasms. It’s so difficult to hear parents gush about “a love like nothing else in the world,” and having that feeling of life-long left-outedness. I struggle to remind myself that having children is not the end-all of life’s opportunities, with my culture working its hardest to convince me otherwise. Thank you for this post.

    Reply
  5. Diane in Maine says:
    February 8, 2013 at 6:46 pm

    Reading posts like Janine Kovac’s simply serve to remind me how grateful I am not to have any Janines in my life. And I didn’t see anything apologetic in her “apology” at all. Thanks for linking on the other blogged responses to her original post; some wonderful writing there. Belated happy blogoversary, Pamela, and thanks for keeping the discussions going, and lively, validating, and informative to boot!

    Reply
  6. deathstar says:
    February 13, 2013 at 3:11 am

    Well, as a Buddhist, I can assure you that having a kid DOES NOT lead to enlightenment. In fact, only life does that. Life – in all its colours and permutations and a seeking spirit that is.

    I did appreciate the Kovac’s apology but really putting your supposed whole point at the bottom of your article full of ridiculous platitudes, and expecting people to ignore all that had gone on before is ridiculous. Still, she is entitled to her point of view. I was also heartened to read all the responses though. (You don’t think she’s going to end up on Ricki Lake, do you?)

    Reply
  7. Pingback: Triggered In A Way I Didn't Expect - Silent Sorority

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

My Books

Popular Posts

  • Identity after Infertility and Failed IVF
  • Infertility Community: A Microcosm of Society Misunderstandings and All
  • Defining Abuse in Assisted Reproductive Technology
  • Casting off Chains of Infertility: Fertility Diary, The Life of Pi and Search for Peace
  • Life After Infertility: One Decade, Many Thoughts
  • IVF Rollercoaster: BBC Radio Show Callers Describe ‘Grueling, Painful, Isolating, Roll of Dice’
  • Strong At The Broken Places
  • Ending Fertility Treatment Equated with Madness?
  • The Invisibleness of Infertility: To Pass or Not to Pass?
  • Dear Abby Strikes Out On Infertility, Childless Not By Choice Question

Subscribe to New Blog Posts

 Subscribe in a reader

Archives

Tags

Avalanche bioethics change Childless childlessness conflict culture egg freezing emotions expectations fertility industry fertility treatment friendships grief growth guest post healing health heroines identity infertility IVF Jessica Hepburn Jody Day journey lessons loss media motherhood myths narrative non-moms psychology reinvention relationships research RESOLVE silent sorority society stigma survival trauma travel truths what ifs

Categories

  • An Act of Kindness
  • Another Perspective
  • Bioethics
  • Book Musings
  • Changing Perceptions
  • Choices
  • Different Than I Expected
  • Documentary
  • Fortitude
  • Guest Post
  • Linking Around
  • Movies
  • News Reports and Studies
  • Pandemic
  • Pop Culture
  • Psychology
  • Relationships
  • Remembrance
  • Spontaneity
  • Strength Personified
  • Tapestry of Voices
  • The Cycle Relay Forum
  • Uncategorized
  • What I Wish I'd Know Then

Recent Comments

  • Pamela Tsigdinos on In Limbo Once Again: Long COVID This Time
  • Cathy Broadwell on In Limbo Once Again: Long COVID This Time
  • Pamela Tsigdinos on In Limbo Once Again: Long COVID This Time
  • dublinerInDeutschland on In Limbo Once Again: Long COVID This Time
  • Pamela Tsigdinos on In Limbo Once Again: Long COVID This Time

Blogroll

  • A Blank New Page
  • Bent Not Broken
  • Childless By Marriage
  • Conscious Childless Elderwomen
  • Des meandres aux etoiles (French)
  • Different Shores
  • Elaine OK (German)
  • Ever Upward
  • Femme Sans Enfant (French)
  • Finding A Different Path
  • Gateway Women
  • Infertile Phoenix
  • Infertility Honesty
  • It's Inconceivable
  • Jessica Hepburn's Blog
  • Just Being
  • Lavender Luz
  • Lesley Pyne
  • Life Without Baby blog
  • MSNBC – Life After IVF
  • No Kidding in NZ
  • Other side of the threshold (Swedish)
  • ReproTechTruths
  • Sitrrup Queen's Blogroll
  • SlidingDoors
  • Slow Swimmers & Fried Eggs
  • The Dove Cote
  • The Empty Cradle (Brisbane)
  • The Infertility Voice
  • The Next 15,000 Days
  • The NotMom
  • The Road Less Travelled
  • Uber Barrens Club
  • Walk in Our Shoes
© 2023 Silent Sorority | Powered by Superbs Personal Blog theme